MACD Crossfire
by Jean Carlos Martins Roso · MT5
Loading...
Loading...
Browse all reviews, rankings, guides, strategies, and trust documents.
Live MetaTrader terminals from FxRobotEasy accounts. Every capture is watermarked and hash-stamped, and opens its own public report.
The player loads from YouTube only after you press play.
Summary
MACD Classic Smoothed is a well-regarded MT5 indicator by Shahabeddin Baset with a 4.89/5 rating and no price listed; verified live stats are not available. Traders favor its smoothed MACD lines for cleaner trend signals, but it shares limits common to indicators—no guaranteed performance, sensitivity to spread and slippage, and potential drawdown under volatile conditions. Alternatives range from timers and EAs to extraction tools priced between $99 and $149, with some free/N/A listings. FxRobotEasy independently reviews all products; choose based on style, account size, and risk tolerance rather than rating alone.
Retail forex traders compare MACD Classic Smoothed with alternatives because they need clarity on signal quality, execution impact, and real-world usability. MACD Classic Smoothed is an MT5 indicator praised for smoothing classic MACD outputs, but many traders want tools that add automation, better entry timing, or risk control. Platform realities matter: broker spreads, execution speed, and rules on EAs can change results; slippage and margin requirements affect drawdown. Price and verified live stats are often missing, so independent reviews help. FxRobotEasy independently reviews all products and highlights where indicator-only solutions differ from EAs and utility tools.
| Metric | MACD Classic SmoothedMain Product | Trendopedia Ai Our bot | MACD Crossfire | MACD Circles | MacD Custom Indicator MTF Plus | MACD Buy Sell KPG |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 0.0 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Price | N/A | $149 | $69.7 | $35 | N/A | N/A |
| ROI | N/A | +291.1% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Max Drawdown | N/A | 22.0% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Win Rate | N/A | 56.4% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Profit Factor | N/A | 1.48 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Total Trades | N/A | 429 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Downloads | 0 | N/A | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Links |
ROI, drawdown, win rate, profit factor and trade counts for MQL5 listings are FxRobotEasy modelled Strategy Tester aggregates — simulated, not live or broker-verified. Rating, price and downloads come from the MQL5 Market listing. The FxRobotEasy column is different in kind: those rows are one published trading account, read live from app.fxroboteasy.com at page build, not a modelled run. It is not like-for-like with the columns beside it, and the per-row winner marker compares a live account against simulations. Its rating and downloads are not tracked here.
MACD Classic Smoothed, authored by Shahabeddin Baset for MT5, scores 4.89/5 and is positioned as a refined take on the classic MACD with extra smoothing to reduce noise. Strengths include clearer trend visualization, potentially fewer false crossovers, and straightforward interpretation for trend-following traders. Weaknesses are inherent to indicator-only tools: it does not execute trades, backtestable live-statistics are not available, and performance is sensitive to broker spreads and execution. Price is listed as N/A and no verified performance stats are available. It suits discretionary traders who prefer visual signals and manual entries, those who combine indicators with risk management rules, and traders on stable, low-spread accounts. Remember that drawdown risk remains, and indicators do not remove the need for position sizing or adherence to broker rules.
by Jean Carlos Martins Roso · MT5
by Fabrizio Ceci · MT5
by German Pablo Gori · MT5
by Le Uyen Phuong Nguyen · MT5
MACD Classic Smoothed is a solid indicator choice for traders who want cleaner MACD signals on MT5; its 4.89/5 rating reflects user approval but live verification is not available and the listed price is N/A. Alternatives offer timing tools, extraction utilities, and full EAs priced between $99 and $149 or N/A. Match tool choice to trading style: use the indicator for discretionary setups, choose EAs for automation, and use utilities for timing or signal filtering. Remember broker rules, spreads, execution, and drawdown risks influence outcomes. FxRobotEasy independently reviews these products and also verifies a set of in-house bots if you need pre-validated automated options.
Whether it’s worth buying depends on your style. MACD Classic Smoothed is an MT5 indicator with a 4.89/5 rating and price listed as N/A; no verified live stats are available. It’s useful if you want cleaner MACD crossovers for discretionary entries, but it won’t manage risk or execute trades. Test on demo accounts, consider broker spreads and slippage, and combine with strict money management before using live capital.
There is no single best alternative; it depends on your needs. For timing, Haven Candle Timer Countdown helps with candle-close discipline. For automation, PZ Stop And Reverse EA MT5 ($149) or Market Anomalies EA ($99) provide different EA strategies. Ultimate Extractor ($100) adds signal filtration. Neon Shadow EA MT5 is another MT5 automation option. All alternatives lack verified live stats, so demo testing and attention to broker spreads and drawdown potential are essential.
Broker rules, spreads, and execution materially affect indicator-driven and automated strategies. High spreads widen effective entry/exit costs, slippage changes realized prices, and broker restrictions can limit EA features. Drawdowns may deepen if execution is poor or margin requirements tighten. Always test on the broker you plan to use, validate settings on a demo account, and factor spreads and allowed slippage into your risk management to avoid unexpected losses.
While evaluating MACD Classic Smoothed and its alternatives, consider Trendopedia Ai, developed by FxRobotEasy. Its review page covers the strategy, settings and the published trading accounts. The figures below come from one published account, read live from app.fxroboteasy.com; the date they were computed is shown with them, and they are absent when that account has no closed trades to report.
+291.1%
Total Return
22.0%
Max Drawdown
56%
Win Rate
429
Total Trades