SD Crystal Heikin Ashi
by Patel Dipeshkumar Ramanbhai · MT5
Loading...
Loading...
Browse all reviews, rankings, guides, strategies, and trust documents.
Live MetaTrader terminals from FxRobotEasy accounts. Every capture is watermarked and hash-stamped, and opens its own public report.
The player loads from YouTube only after you press play.
Summary
Scylla AI is a $279 MT5 expert advisor by Novin Ghasemi Nik rated 5/5 on listing but with no verified performance statistics. It aims to provide automated trade management and signal execution for retail forex traders comfortable with MT5. Alternatives span tools for timing, trend reversal, anomaly-based strategies, extraction-focused systems, and shadow/price action EAs, with prices from $99 to $149 where listed and several vendors not disclosing price data. Traders should weigh strategy fit, broker constraints, spreads, potential drawdown, account sizing, and availability of verified live or backtested results. FxRobotEasy independently reviews every product included here.
Retail forex traders compare Scylla AI with alternatives because buying an MT5 expert advisor is as much about strategy fit and operational reality as it is about advertised features. Scylla AI, authored by Novin Ghasemi Nik, is listed at $279 with a 5/5 rating on its marketplace page, but there are no verified live or independently audited statistics to back performance claims. That gap is common: several comparable products in this roundup also show high ratings but lack verified stats. When evaluating EAs you must consider broker rules, minimal and variable spreads, execution latency, slippage, available leverage, margin requirements, and the potential for extended drawdowns during adverse market conditions. Strategy transparency and parameter control are critical: some systems aim for mean reversion, some for breakout capture, others for trend-following or anomaly detection, and each behaves differently under the same market microstructure and fee schedule. Retail traders should also assess support, update cadence, and whether the developer supplies sample backtests, stress tests, or walk-forward analyses. FxRobotEasy independently reviews each product in this article, aiming to synthesize listing details, published features, pricing, and practical considerations so traders can shortlist candidates for demo testing. No product here is guaranteed to produce profits; the objective is to clarify strengths, weaknesses, and operational fit so you can match an EA to your risk tolerance, account size, and broker environment before risking live capital.
| Metric | Scylla AIMain Product | Trendopedia Ai Our bot | SD Crystal Heikin Ashi | Scraper Gold | SD FirmPrism Pro | Scorpio Enix |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 0.0 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Price | $279 | $149 | N/A | $30 | N/A | N/A |
| ROI | N/A | +291.1% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Max Drawdown | N/A | 22.0% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Win Rate | N/A | 56.4% | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Profit Factor | N/A | 1.48 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Total Trades | N/A | 429 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Downloads | 0 | N/A | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Links |
ROI, drawdown, win rate, profit factor and trade counts for MQL5 listings are FxRobotEasy modelled Strategy Tester aggregates — simulated, not live or broker-verified. Rating, price and downloads come from the MQL5 Market listing. The FxRobotEasy column is different in kind: those rows are one published trading account, read live from app.fxroboteasy.com at page build, not a modelled run. It is not like-for-like with the columns beside it, and the per-row winner marker compares a live account against simulations. Its rating and downloads are not tracked here.
Scylla AI is an expert advisor for MetaTrader 5 developed by Novin Ghasemi Nik and listed at $279 with a 5/5 rating on its product page. The listing emphasizes automated trade execution and algorithmic management tailored to retail forex accounts, but it is important to underline that there are no verified performance statistics available for Scylla AI. That absence does not disqualify the product, but it does increase the importance of demo testing, parameter validation, and conservative exposure sizing. Strengths of Scylla AI likely include MT5 integration, configurable settings, and a single-vendor packaged solution, which suits traders who prefer a plug-and-play approach and polished interface within MT5. The 5/5 rating suggests positive reception among buyers on the marketplace, but marketplace ratings do not replace independent verification of returns, drawdown, and stability under varying market regimes. Weaknesses include the lack of published live or third-party audited track records and potential overreliance on vendor-supplied backtests. Traders should ask for sample logs, strategy descriptions, risk controls like stop loss and max drawdown limits, and update policies. Platform realities are central: broker spreads, commission models, and order execution quality will materially influence realized results. Scylla AI may perform differently with an ECN broker at low spreads compared with a high-spread retail broker. Leverage and margin requirements amplify both gains and losses, and every EA can suffer extended losing runs; thus drawdown risk management and correct lot-sizing are essential. Scylla AI is best suited to traders who (1) require an MT5-native EA, (2) are comfortable performing forward tests on a demo account, and (3) can validate settings against realistic spreads and slippage. For traders seeking verified live performance or detailed third-party audits, the lack of public verified stats is a drawback; plan to operate on a demo and progressively size live capital only after observing behavior across multiple market conditions. FxRobotEasy independently reviews Scylla AI as part of its comparative coverage to help traders understand feature sets, pricing, and practical trade-offs.
by Patel Dipeshkumar Ramanbhai · MT5
by Kriscandra Rumbang Atmaja · MT5
by Patel Dipeshkumar Ramanbhai · MT5
by Nur Wahyogi · MT5
FxRobotEasy evaluates expert advisors and trading tools using a consistent, transparent approach that balances marketplace listings, documented features, pricing, and operational realities. We collect vendor-provided materials such as strategy descriptions, parameter lists, screenshots, and any available backtests. We prioritize independently verified live statistics and third-party audits when available; if verified stats are absent, we clearly mark that data as not available. Key metrics we consider include strategy logic transparency, risk controls (stop loss, drawdown limits), configurability, platform compatibility (MT4/MT5), and price. We also test installation and basic functionality on demo accounts to observe execution behavior and to highlight broker-related factors: spreads, commissions, slippage, and order execution speed. Limitations of our methodology include reliance on vendor-supplied backtests when third-party live data is missing, which can be subject to overfitting and data-snooping bias. We do not run every EA continuously in live accounts for all possible brokers; instead we recommend demo-forwarding across the specific broker and instruments the trader intends to use. FxRobotEasy independently reviews every product featured and flags where pricing or stats are not available. We avoid revenue or profit guarantees and always advise conservative position sizing, realistic expectations about drawdowns, and staged capital deployment following demo validation.
Scylla AI presents as a polished MT5 expert advisor by Novin Ghasemi Nik priced at $279 and carrying a 5/5 listing rating, but the absence of verified live statistics is an important consideration for risk-conscious retail traders. If you prioritize an MT5-native packaged EA and prefer vendor support and a marketplace reputation, Scylla AI is a defensible choice provided you rigorously demo-test it and manage position sizing to control drawdown. Alternatives in this comparison cover different trader needs: PZ Stop And Reverse offers a mechanical trend flip at $149; Market Anomalies is an inexpensive $99 experiment in nonstandard logic; Ultimate Extractor is a $100 tactical tool; and Haven Candle Timer and Neon Shadow have missing price data and no verified stats. All alternatives are rated 5/5 on marketplaces but lack independently audited histories. Practical decision-making should factor in broker spreads, commissions, and execution quality because these variables materially affect live results. For traders who require verified performance history, consider also looking at FxRobotEasy’s portfolio of independently reviewed and verified bots where available. Ultimately, match strategy style, risk tolerance, and broker conditions to the EA you choose, start with thorough demo testing, and scale live capital slowly only after consistent, repeatable results under your chosen broker environment.
Whether Scylla AI is worth buying depends on your objectives and due diligence. The product is listed at $279 with a 5/5 marketplace rating, but there are no verified live statistics available. If you value an MT5-native EA and can devote time to demo testing, parameter tuning, and conservative sizing, it may be a fit. Avoid purchasing sight-unseen for large capital allocations; demo-forward and confirm behaviour under realistic spreads and slippage before scaling live.
The best alternative depends on the strategy you seek. For mechanical trend flips, PZ Stop And Reverse EA MT5 at $149 is a clear comparator. If you want low-cost experimentation, Market Anomalies EA at $99 could be attractive. For timing aids rather than automation, Haven Candle Timer helps with candle/session timing. No single product is objectively best; match the alternative to your trading style and demo-test on your broker.
Verified statistics are very important because they reduce reliance on vendor backtests that may be overfitted. Third-party audited live results or verified track records provide evidence the strategy survives real-market frictions like latency, slippage, and changing volatility. When verified stats are not available, prioritize demo testing, request sample logs, and use small, staged live allocations.
Broker spreads and commissions directly affect an EA’s profitability, especially for strategies with many trades or tight stop targets. Wider spreads increase break-even thresholds and intensify slippage costs. Execution latency and order filling policies can turn a profitable backtest into a losing live run. Always test EAs on the specific broker and account type you plan to use to measure realistic costs.
You can run multiple EAs on the same MT5 account, but be cautious about correlated strategies, cumulative margin usage, and aggregate drawdown. Ensure individual EA risk settings combine safely: set per-EA max risk, monitor total exposure, and be prepared to disable systems that interact negatively during high volatility events.
On demo, confirm installation and stability, verify trade logic against different market sessions, measure sensitivity to spreads and slippage, run for several market cycles, and test money management settings. Track drawdown patterns, win/loss distribution, and maximum consecutive losses. Use the same broker and account type planned for live trading to capture realistic execution.
FxRobotEasy independently reviews all products included in this comparison, synthesizing vendor materials, marketplace data, and hands-on demo testing where feasible. We flag when verified live statistics are absent and advise users to demo-test and validate across their chosen broker. Our reviews aim to inform rather than guarantee results, and we do not issue performance guarantees.
While evaluating Scylla AI and its alternatives, consider Trendopedia Ai, developed by FxRobotEasy. Its review page covers the strategy, settings and the published trading accounts. The figures below come from one published account, read live from app.fxroboteasy.com; the date they were computed is shown with them, and they are absent when that account has no closed trades to report.
+291.1%
Total Return
22.0%
Max Drawdown
56%
Win Rate
429
Total Trades